Tuesday, January 27, 2015

Superintendent's 2014 Evaluation

Mississippi School Boards Association
Superintendent Evaluation Instrument
2014 Edition
 
Directions: Each board member receives the evaluation in advance of the board meeting and rates each standard by placing either an S (Satisfactory) or U (Unsatisfactory) in the box to the right of the indicators listed below the standard.  At the board meeting the board discusses the evaluation and comes to agreement on an overall numerical rating on each standard based on the rating of satisfactory or unsatisfactory on each indicator.  (Example: Standard 1 has 10 indicators.  If the board determine that the superintendent had made satisfactory progress on 8 out of 10 of the indicators, the numerical rating would be 80%.)
 
Any indicator receiving a "U" necessitates (1) a written response from the board to he superintendent specifying the reason(s) for the unsatisfactory rating and (2) a corrective action a plan written by the superintendent and approved b the board specifying the action the superintendent will take in the future to correct the deficiency.  Such corrective action plan shall include measurable indicators of success (as agreed upon by the board with input from the superintendent) that clearly delineates the action(s) the superintendent must take to avoid a future unsatisfactory rating in the identified area.
 
Standard 1: Provides leadership to the SCHOOL BOARD in implementing the district's vision, mission and goals.  Overall rating: 80% 
 
1.1 Accomplishes the goals of the board as measured by the "indicators of success" on the District Report Card. U
 
1.2 Collaborates with the Board in the preparation of long-term and short-term operational and instructional goals, which are objectively measurable as pre-determined through "indicators of success." U
 
1.3 Develops action plans with measurable "indicators of success" on the agreed upon goals. S
 
1.4 Collaborates with the Board in the preparation of annual monitoring intervals for all adopted goals. S
 
1.5 Collaborates with the Board in determining the reporting format to be used at monitoring intervals for adopted goals. S
 
1.6 Collaborates with the Board in the development of a Board "Annual Calendar" and assures that this calendar is included in the Board's monthly Board meeting packet. S
 
1.7 Provides system data and leadership to the Board at school board meetings regarding the status of and progress made toward accomplishment of Board adopted goals. S
 
1.8 Implements and evaluates the effectiveness of the adopted action plans. S
 
1.9 Repots annually to the Board on the status of goals attainment as measured by the pre-determined, "indicators of success" / measurable objectives. S
 
1.10 Effectively oversees and monitors the planning and evaluation of curriculum and instruction programs. S 
 
Standard 2: Assists the SCHOOL BOARD in the continuous improvement of the school district. Overall rating: 75%





2.1 Assists the Board in meeting or exceeding the required training requirements of Mississippi.  Overall Rating: S

2.2 Informs the Board about current trends and developments in education.  Overall Rating: U

2.3 Prepares reports on progress made toward (1) the accomplishment of the district's goals, (2) the strengths and improvements needed in the school district, (3) any compelling problems(s) or emerging issues(s).  Overall Rating: S

2.4 Participates in professional activities to enhance knowledge and skills. Overall Rating: S



Standard 3: Assists the SCHOOL BOARD to implement the district's organizational structure. Overall Rating: 0% 

3.1 Operates through adopted policies as the district's chief executive officer. Overall Rating: U

3.2 Follows the Board's adopted Code of Ethics and Professional Governance Standards.  Overall Rating: U


Standard 4: Provides leadership to the SCHOOL BOARD in policy development and policy implementation.  Overall Rating: 75%

4.1 Informs the Board about current rules, regulations, and accreditation standards of the Mississippi Board of Education and of applicable state and federal laws. Overall Rating: S

4.2 Adheres to the Board of policy on "Adoption of Polices" when developing policy or presenting new or revised policies to the Board for consideration. Overall Rating: S

4.3 Correlates applicable policies to agenda items at Board meetings. Overall Rating: U

4.4 Maintains an distributes all adopted policies. Overall Rating: S

4.5 Ensures all policies are updated an current and that the staff and community have access to such policies. Overall Rating: S

4.6 Provides recommendations on all policies presented to the Board. Overall Rating: S

4.7 Seeks out staff and public opinion on applicable, proposed policies an reports the findings to the Board.  Overall Rating: S

4.8 Implements and explains policies and actions  the School Board. Overall Rating: U



Standard 5: Meets established requirements in developing and conducting Board meetings.  Overall rating: 100%

5.1 Posts all meetings by the Board in accordance with the Open Meetings Act.  Overall Rating: S

5.2 Follows the Board's adopted policy on conducting effective school board meetings.  Overall Rating: S

5.3 Maintains the official School Board Minutes and other records that pertain to the State's Open Records Act.  Overall Rating: S


Standard 6: Provides leadership as superintendent to the SCHOOL BOARD in personnel management.  Overall Rating: 100%

6.1 Communicates Board beliefs/vision/mission/goals to school personnel. Overall Rating: S

6.2 Provides leadership to and general supervision of all school district employees. Overall Rating: S

6.3 Implements staff evaluation processes consistent with the state's evaluation system to ensure fair and equitable evaluation of all personnel in the district.  Overall Rating: S

6.4 Maintains updated job descriptions for all staff. Overall Rating: S

6.5 Maintains an updated, Board approved school district organizational chart.  Overall Rating: S

6.6 Has a Board approved plan for the recruitment of personnel.  Overall Rating: S



Standard 7: Provides accurate data to assist the SCHOOL BOARD in financial management: Overall Rating: 77%

7.1 Coordinates with the Board in developing the budget.  Overall Rating: S

7.2 Ensures that the board approves guidelines for budget decision making. Overall Rating: S

7.3 Develops the proposed budget following adopted budget policies that outline the budget development process and timelines to meet state and local requirements. Overall Rating: S

7.4 Implements and administers the budget in accordance with Board directives and policy. Overall Rating: U

7.5 Administers the approved budget within Board-established spending amounts and recommends budget amendments.  Overall Rating: U

7.6 Prepares monthly financial reports on the status of the budget - reports to include, at minimum, money budgeted, received and expended to date in all budgeted areas.  Overall Rating: S

7.7 Prepares and presents to the Board annually a five-year trend report on the school district's fund balance.  Overall Rating: N/A?

7.8 Maintains the district's financial records and cooperates with auditors annually to audit financial records. Overall Rating: S

7.9 Provides the Board with a copy of the annual financial audit along with an executive summary of any findings/problems.  Overall Rating: S

7.10 Reports annually to the Board the findings o the District's financial audit.  Overall Rating: S

7.11 Provides the Board with monthly reports on all/any financial transactions involving sixteenth section monies.  Overall Rating: N/A?


Standard 8: Provides leadership to the SCHOOL BOARD in Board, staff and community relationships.  Overall Rating: 50%

8.1 Demonstrates respect and cooperation in professional relationships with the Board and individual Board members, staff, and community.  Overall Rating: U

8.2 Recognizes and protects the chain of command concept.  Overall Rating: U

8.3 Works with the Board to develop ad implement a process that encourages and seeks the input of staff at all levels in decision-making on significant issues where it s appropriate.  Overall Rating: U

8.4 Provides the Board with information on training opportunities, seminars, and conferences applicable to Board professional development and, whenever possible, attends Board training sessions with the Board.  Overall Rating: S

8.5 Develops a process to receive input from citizens n matters relating to the school district and communicates with the community.  Overall Rating: S

8.6 Implements he adopted Board policies on media communications.  Overall Rating: S

8.7 Ensures that each school has a community engagement plan.  Overall Rating: S

8.8 Ensures community easy access to the school district's "Annual Report Card."  Overall Rating: S




This evaluation was signed on 7 Feb 2014 by:


Board President: Tomaka Cotton
Board Secretary: Marilyn Young
Superintendent: Bernard S. Chandler

Blogger's Notes and Analysis:

1. Our School Board has 5 members.  Therefore, it would take at least 3 members to come to any consensus.  That means at least 3 members would have to vote satisfactory for an S to be entered on the evaluation.  Also, at least 3 members would have to vote unsatisfactory for a U to be entered on the evaluation.  What is not represented in this evaluation are the votes of the remaining 2 members of the School Board.

2. There are 8 Standards in this evaluation. 
Standard 1:  80%
Standard 2:  75%
Standard 3:   0%
Standard 4:  75%
Standard 5:100%
Standard 6:100%
Standard 7: 77%
Standard 8: 50%

3. The total value of the 8 Standards is: 557% divided by 8 = 69.65%

4. There are 52 subcategories on this evaluation.  Of the 52 subcategories there are 38 satisfactory; 12 unsatisfactory and 2 not applicable.

So, here is the question: Who gets a $15,000 raise with an evaluation of 69.65%?  Answer: The Tunica County Superintendent of Education.

Who voted for this raise?

District 1: Marilyn Young: No
District 2: Tomaka Cotton: Yes
District 3: Larry Braziel: No
District 4: Delois Hardiman: Yes
District 5: Joe Anderson: Yes

Please let me know in the comments section if I have any of this information wrong.





 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 



Thursday, January 22, 2015

Letter to the Editor from Dennis Taylor

This letter appeared in the Tunica Times 23 Jan 2015 edition.  Really happy to see Dennis take the time to write to the newspaper.  I didn't attend the School Board Meeting on 14 Jan 2015 but had heard this discussed a couple of times.  The last time I heard about this unfortunate display of rudeness was last night and I vowed to contact my representative on the Board, who is also the Board President.

So, here is Dennis' letter:

"School Board meeting disappoints
 
On January 14, 2015, I attended a School Board Meeting, where during the meeting: I was totally disappointed in what I witnessed between the Superintendent and several Board Members.  During an outpour of concerns by people in the community, I found it very childish and disrespectful for the Superintendent and also the President of the Board to turn their backs and mock jokingly to the community as they spoke on their concerns regarding the education of our Future Global Leaders.
 
The Superintendent and the Board President found it amusing as some concerned citizens spoke concerning important issues pertaining to our schools.  The board works with its superintendent as a leadership team to identify the overall mission of the school district and the plans that will be put in place as the roadmap to fulfill the mission.  This has yet to happen!
 
A single board member has no power.  Behaving ethically is a serious obligation.  Not only does your community expect you to be impeccably ethical, so does the sate law.  As school leaders, you've been entrusted with serving our communities and its children.
 
School Board President and Superintendent, your moral and spiritual health is required because, what really matters isn't power, position, money, etc.  It's the honorable way you build relationships with others and the difference you make in their lives that count.  The board is obligated to be equitable, ensuring the district serves children whose needs and strengths are broadly diverse.  Show some respect for you community members and their opinions, even when you don't agree.
 
It's your job to do your best to be open, honest, fair, and impartial in all matters.  Remember always that your first and greatest concern must be the educational welfare of all the students attending the Tunica School District.  As a leader you are seen as a person of power,  When you speak, you speak for the district as a whole.  The world is looking at you and making assumptions.  As of now, those assumptions aren't decent."
Dennis Taylor
 
Note from the blogger:  I have not heard from my representative on the Tunica County Board of Education.  When and if there is a response, I will add it to this post.  As of now, I am very disappointed in my representative.




I spoke with my School Board representative on 22 Jan 2015.  I live in Beat 2.  Therefore, my representative is the President of the School Board.  She denies what is represented about her in Mr. Taylor's letter and indicated she will write a rebuttal to Mr. Taylor' letter and will send it to the Tunica Times.

I have had previous conversations with my representative about the $15K raise that was awarded to the Superintendent on 14 May 2014.  As recorded in the School Board minutes for that date, the vote to approve this raise in salary is recorded as follows:

Beat 1: Marilyn Young: No
Beat 2: Tomaka Cotton: Yes
Beat 3: Larry Braziel: No
Beat 4: Delois Hardiman: Yes
Beat 5: Joe Anderson: Yes

At the end on our conversation, I asked my representative how many "unsatisfactory" indicators were on the Superintendent's 2014 Evaluation?  The President of the Board indicated there was one unsatisfactory indicator.  Please read the next post on this blog to view the Superintendent's 2014 Evaluation.  This Evaluation is signed by:

Board President: Tomaka Cotton: 2/7/2014
Board Secretary: Marilyn Young: 2/7/2014
Superintendent**: Bernard S. Chandler: 2/7/2014

**The superintendent's signature does not necessarily indicate complete agreement with this evaluation but acknowledges that the performance discussion has occurred.

Note from the blogger:  I have had this evaluation in my possession since 11 Jan 2014.
 



Saturday, January 3, 2015

Tunica County Bracing For 5% Pay Cut from FOX13

The following is the transcript of a Fox13 video clip with Tom Dees reporting.  The story aired on 29 Dec 2014.  Following the transcript you will find a reprint of the text with a rebuttal to the story highlighted in yellow.

"TUNICA COUNTY, Miss (Fox13) - A less than happy new year is coming for employees of Tunica County, as they expect pay cuts in 2015.  Some of the cuts could affect public safety.

County supervisors say it's a five-percent pay cut across the board.  The cuts are stiff enough that some say they are worried employees will go elsewhere.

Tunica County Supervisor Cedric Burnett said the cuts are stiff enough to hurt pubic safety.

'Well it wouldn't be good for the sheriff's department,' Supervisor Burnett said. 'We are lower paid than the City of Memphis and Shelby County (in Tennessee) and Desoto County (in northern Mississippi) so we would lose a lot of people to the north and east.'

Supervisor Burnett says he is the only supervisor who voted against the five-percent salary and pay cut.

'I would say it could have been if we decreased salaried employees through attrition from the beginning of the term,' he said.

Supervisor James Dunn said that he disagrees with Supervisor Burnett, saying the cuts were necessary and if the county did not cut pay it would have to cut jobs due to a decrease in gaming revenue.

But, Supervisor Burnett said the county wasted millions of dollars on things like community centers that were not needed.

'Yeah we wasted money in the past but we could afford to waste money in the past,' Supervisor Burnett said.  'Eight years ago we had a lot of money so we could waste a lot of money but now you don't have a lot of money so you shouldn't.'

Supervisor Dunn said the county may still have to cut jobs if the pay cuts are not enough, but it's unclear how many positions would be affected."

End of transcript.

Begin rebuttal:

"TUNICA COUNTY, Miss (Fox13) - A less than happy new year is coming for employees of Tunica County, as they expect pay cuts in 2015.  Some of the cuts could affect public safety.

County supervisors say it's a five-percent pay cut across the board.  The cuts are stiff enough that some say they are worried employees will go elsewhere.  Tunica County is overstaffed by about 50% so says the Stennis Report.  You may find our post on 3 Feb 2014 interesting on this matter.  If any employee would like to earn more money by going elsewhere, that would be good for Tunica County and for the employee.

Tunica County Supervisor Cedric Burnett said the cuts are stiff enough to hurt public safety.  This statement is made of emotion and not facts.  Our Sheriff's Department is overstaffed.  So, again, if employees want to get higher paying employment elsewhere, this would be good for them and good for Tunica County.

'Well it wouldn't be good for the sheriff's department,' Supervisor Burnett said. 'We are lower paid than the City of Memphis and Shelby County (in Tennessee) and Desoto County (in northern Mississippi) so we would lose a lot of people to the north and east.'  Again, the Sheriff's Department is overstaffed. If employees want more pay, it is their right to seek a higher paying job.  I have not researched the validity of Burnett's statement about pay in other counties.  However, perhaps the pay in the locations Burnett mentions have higher taxes to support higher pay for their employees.  The fact that we had falling revenue and hardly any taxes is a failing of Burnett and others before 1 Jan 2012.

Supervisor Burnett says he is the only supervisor who voted against the five-percent salary and pay cut.  Yes, this is true which shows Burnett's complete lack of understanding of the financial problems we are facing.

'I would say it could have been if we decreased salaried employees through attrition from the beginning of the term,' he said.  Oh now he says this.  How about decreasing some of the huge salaries we are paying.  Has this guy even read the Stennis Report?  News flash Burnett: One third of our employees are overpaid.  Why haven't you, as a sitting Supervisor, suggested reducing those salaries?

Supervisor James Dunn said that he disagrees with Supervisor Burnett, saying the cuts were necessary and if the county did not cut pay it would have to cut jobs due to a decrease in gaming revenue.

But, Supervisor Burnett said the county wasted millions of dollars on things like community centers that were not needed.  This statement is ridiculous.  Firstly, are you talking about the Robinsonville Community Center?  The RCC was and is needed as our population growth has been in North Tunica County.  However, the financial timing of  this project was wrong. In fact, the timing could not have been worse.  Secondly, let's talk about other projects you supported without so much as a feasibility study to show the project was needed or we could support any of these entities. I'm talking about the Tunica Airport, the Battle Arena, RiverPark, Tunica National, etc.  Burnett are you now willing to stand-up and admit your mistakes in supporting these projects or are you going to continue to point the finger at someone else?

'Yeah we wasted money in the past but we could afford to waste money in the past,' Supervisor Burnett said.  'Eight years ago we had a lot of money so we could waste a lot of money but now you don't have a lot of money so you shouldn't.'  This statement says about all we need to know about Cedric Burnett.  WOW!!!

Supervisor Dunn said the county may still have to cut jobs if the pay cuts are not enough, but it's unclear how many positions would be affected."

End of rebuttal.

Friday, January 2, 2015

Congressional Record Honoring Will Ellis Pittman

     
Look what I found online:  Congratulations Mr. Pittman
   

   
 
 
[Pages E1331-E1332]
 
HONORING ATTORNEY WILL ELLIS PITTMAN
 
                                 HON. BENNIE G. THOMPSON of Mississippi in the House of Representatives
Monday, September 8, 2014
 
Mr. THOMPSON of Mississippi.
 
Mr. Speaker, I rise today to honor Attorney Will Ellis Pittman.

Attorney Pittman was born and raised in Tutwiler, MS. Mr. Pittman is 51 years old. He is the owner and managing member of Pittman & Associates, PLLC law firm in Clarksdale, Mississippi where he also serves as the first African-American County Prosecutor for Coahoma County. Attorney Pittman also serves as the board attorney for the Tunica County Board of Supervisors and is the first African-American to represent the Tunica County Board of Supervisors. Attorney Pittman is recognized amongst family, his community, and his colleagues as a man of wisdom, service, a generous spirit, and passion. He regularly attends and serves on the finance committee of the Galena Missionary Baptist Church in Tutwiler, Mississippi which he grew up in and joined at eight years of age.

Ellis attended and graduated from public high school in Tallahatchie County, Mississippi. After earning his high school diploma, he enlisted in the United States Marine Corps. While in the Marine Corps, Ellis married his high school sweetheart, and they had two (2) children. After being honorably discharged from the Marine Corps, Ellis returned to his home town in Tutwiler.

However, he was unable to find employment anywhere in the delta area. Ellis returned to work and earned a living on the plantation in Tallahatchie County where he grew up. Ellis worked six (6) sometimes seven (7) days a week to provide food, shelter, and the bare necessities for his family. He always knew that if given the opportunity, he would provide them with a better way of life.

After working one full year and saving every penny that he could, Ellis departed for Dallas, Texas where he obtained a job with a janitorial service, cleaning grocery stores at night. Within two months Ellis saved enough funds for a deposit and first months' rent on an apartment. He then returned to Mississippi to get his wife and child and they returned to Dallas, Texas. Within six months, the store at which Ellis was employed took notice of his hard work and daily attendance and the store manager offered him a job as an apprentice baker that provided health insurance, dental, and vision benefits for both him and his family. With this break, Ellis used the extra earnings to provide a better place for his family to stay. Within six months, Ellis had worked his way from an apprentice baker to a journeyman baker and was able to provide his family with the kind of things that he had always dreamed of having.

Although he excelled in his employment, Ellis realized that in order to do more for his family he would have to obtain a college education. At the same time, Ellis desired to return home to be with his elderly father who became ill. So, he applied for and was hired with the Mississippi Department of Corrections as a correctional officer trainee.

He then made plans to attend Mississippi Valley State University to obtain a college degree. Prior to applying to Mississippi Valley State University, the Pittman's home caught on fire in which Ellis received second and third degree burns over a large portion of his body. His wife received severe burns as well. After a month, she passed away from the injuries she sustained from the fire. Ellis remained in the Greenville Burn Center for a month and half before he was released. After a short period of time, he returned to his place of employment at the Mississippi State Penitentiary. The home that he had purchased for his family had burned down, so the Department of Corrections provided him with a house on the grounds for him and his two minor sons to live.

At this point, he made the decision not to attend Mississippi Valley State University due to the drive because he would have to commute. Being a single parent and still having to work, Ellis applied to Delta State University which was closer to where he was living at the penitentiary and he could make the daily commute. He commuted five days a week for three years until he graduated from Delta State University with a degree in criminal justice and political science.

Prior to graduation from Delta State University, Ellis applied to law school at Mississippi College, Thurgood Marshall School of Law, and the University of Mississippi School Of Law. He was accepted for admission at all three law schools. However, he chose to attend the University of Mississippi--School of Law due to the financial aid available for African-American applicants. After obtaining his law degree and license to practice law, Ellis returned to the Mississippi Delta from Memphis, Tennessee and opened Pittman Law Office in Clarksdale, Mississippi in 1996 where he continues to practice to this day.

Ellis has given countless young lawyers, that have recently graduated with no experience and unable to find a job, a position at his law office to give them a start. He realized that most people will do well if given the chance which he learned from personal experience when he needed someone to give him a chance. There has not been a time when a newly admitted lawyer came to Ellis looking for job and was turned down for employment.

Ellis' practice has included representing countless individuals in cases for excessive force, employment discrimination, criminal defense, family law, as well as personal injury and wrongful death.

Attorney Will Ellis Pittman's work ethic, passion, dedication, dependability, and service have made him synonymous with being one of the best, if not the best, attorney around. At the end of the day, Ellis is recognized for his service to God, his family, his country, his community, and the people that seek his help.

[[Page E1332]]

Mr. Speaker, I ask my colleagues to join me in recognizing Attorney Will Ellis Pittman for his dedication to serving this great state and country.                          
       

 


Letter to the Editor from Bob Tuchel

The following letter appeared in the 2 Jan 2015 of the Tunica Times:

Put energy into solving problems
 
Again the cries go out, "Fire Michael Thompson."  This attitude disappoints me.  For months many have said some pretty rough things about three of our County Supervisors, about Michael Thompson, and even my spouse, Barbara Tuchel.  A lot of energy has gone into name calling, making threats, intimidation, and creating distortions of the facts.
 
If as much energy had been put into solving our financial problem, it would be solved and done.  Throughout history those who were aware of human failings told us that emotions were more powerful than the intellect.  So here we are in all our glory howling for blood when the problem is that our expenses are greater than our income.  To hell with the intellect, let's substitute it with emotions.  What kind of people have we become?  It looks more and more as though we are no less than an angry, misguided mob.
 
Why are so many telling stories that have no base in fact or have no relevance to correcting the problem?  I guess it must be fun.  Persons are getting something out of evil stories because they so enjoy repeating them.  There is no sense in asking those out of the county how they view us.  We would ignore their condemnation and derisive laughter and continue to be rock solid in our misguided self-righteousness.  And then what? 
 
We will be placed in receivership and the government would send in a person to run the county.  If you do not understand what that is, think, DETROIT.  Wouldn't the Wall Street Journal have a time replaying the story from many years ago when they wrote about the Casinos in Tunica County, Mississippi?  Now they will write about our inability to manage our "wealth."  Won't we be proud then?



Tuesday, December 23, 2014

22 Dec 2014 BOS's Meeting

The following is our Committee's report at the meeting:

22 Dec 2014: Board of Supervisors’ Meeting @ 5p

Thank you for the appointment this evening.

We have 2 subjects in our presentation tonight. 

The first topic is about the funding you will be voting on tonight.

At your last meeting, we heard from Lyn Arnold how the Chamber and Economic Development became so closely entangled.  At the time, this may have been a good decision.  However, needs have changed and so has our funding. 

Please consider funding Economic Development and not funding the Chamber.  In most communities, funding of a local Chamber of Commerce is obtained through individual, company and corporate memberships.  Our Chamber has been largely funded through our local governments. 

As we transition to an Efficient and Sustainable Government, we will need to replace our lost income with other revenue streams and are in need of Economic Development to attain these goals.
 
Insert comment: As best a I can remember.  At the moment we have citizens attending the pre-employment program at Northwest Community College.  After the course they are supposedly qualified to interview at Schultz or GTA.  My husband, Bob, has been in the industrial training field for many years.  As I understand the process, a prospective employee will be interviewed and hired by the company before being trained.  It appears we may need to take a look at what we are doing as there are many complaints from citizens who are not getting jobs in Tunica County. 

The second topic concerns the recent Opinion piece that ran last week in the Tunica Times.  There is a very long post on the Transparency Blog rebutting a good bit of the Tunica Times offering.  It appears this Opinion blames so many of our troubles on our County Administrator when it is way past time for we, the people of Tunica County to accept the blame for the financial mess we are in and not try to continually transfer this responsibility to someone else. 

I will address one of the three “accomplishments” attributed to Michael Thompson in this Opinion. 

“in the biggest debacle for Tunica County, Caesar’s Entertainment abruptly closed the county’s largest resort property, Harrah’s, throwing over a thousand people out of work, shuttering three hotels, a world class golf course, Cottonwoods, and the resort area’s only true convention facility, and putting an end to a successful program of charter (flights) into Tunica Airport, flights which were drawing visitors from far outside the drive-up market.” 

  1. May I be so bold as to ask, who built a golf course to compete with Cottonwoods and River Bend?  We did.  Not Michael Thompson.
  2. Are you clearly stating that with the closing of Harrah’s, no other casino is bringing charter flights into Tunica Airport? That would be interesting to investigate but again this is not a decision attributed to Michael Thompson.  We the people of Tunica County are the people who allowed this airport to be built without the benefit of a feasibility study.
  3. Then there is the statement about “throwing over a thousand people out of work.”  The month Harrah’s closed, Tunica County’s unemployment rate was 17% for Jun 2014.  Jul was 18%.  Aug was 15%.  Sep was 13% and Oct was 12%.  Not much of a change from before Harrah’s closed.  You know what else this might show us?  Not many Tunicans were employed at Harrah's.  Don’t know for sure but maybe.
As was stated earlier in this report, there is a more extensive rebuttal on the Transparency Blog.  In closing I would like to ask the Tunica Times to recognize the factual mistakes made in this “Opinion” piece and to run an apology to Michael Thompson in their next issue.  To show you are sincere this apology needs to be front page and above the fold. 

In the meantime, Michael, I would like to offer an apology from the Tuchel household for all of the mean spirited things that have been done to you and said about you since your arrival in Tunica County.
 
End of Presentation.
 
In other business, the Board did vote to fund the Chamber for $17k.  James Dunn did say that 90% of what the Chamber does is Economic Development.  Michael Thompson said he was working with Lyn Arnold on a proposal.
 
There was something said by James Dunn about first time home buyers but there was no discussion or voting of any kind.

Randy Stewart presented architect's drawings for the community safe house.  The drawings were approved and Stewart was reminded by Dunn to keep this project within the bid as there is no room for project change orders.  My note:  Even though 95% of this project is covered by a grant, do we really need this?  Has there been a feasibility study?  And 95% of what number?

Update 24 Dec 204: This was left out of the original post.  At one point in the meeting, James Dunn asked Adrian McKay to provide a list of all of the employees who have been effected by the recent 5% reduction in pay.  Comment: There is no problem with asking for or getting the list.  This is just another example of a supervisor not working through the County Administrator.  Another way to look at this is the employee is put in a position of taking orders from 2 different bosses.  This needs to change from the way things used to be done.
  
Cedric Burnett did not attend the meeting.

The meeting was adjourned.  The next Board of Supervisor's Meeting is Mon, 5 Jan 2015 at 5p.

Friday, December 19, 2014

19 Dec 2014 Rebuttal to Tunica Times Editorial...

"It's past time for Thompson to go"

Below is the entire Opinion with my comments highlighted in yellow and my notes highlighted in blue.  Grab a coffee and take a seat...this is going to be a long one.  By the way, how come neither Brooks nor Meg put their name to this opinion?  All of us are required to do so.  Just saying...here we go.

"This month, Michael Thompson is 'celebrating' one year as administrator for Tunica County. Yes, and one of his accomplishments is showing the public our broken tax structure.  Past County Administrators and Boards of Supervisors failed to take action by adjusting our tax structure to keep pace with falling gaming revenues and property values.  We have been living in a fool's paradise.

But we wonder if this anniversary of sorts holds any joy for him or if he wishes he had never heard of this place.  Are you kidding me?  Our Sheriff entraps him and many of our citizens are blaming him for our own misplaced trust and stupidity.  I feel your pain Michael.  Many folks in the white community hate me too and for the same reason: Telling the truth.  You see Michael, it' okay for false arrests and entrapment to go on as long as it is not one of them.

Thompson's general demeanor in recent months, as county finances have steadily worsened, has changed dramatically.  Where once he entered the meeting room smiling, laughing and greeting people in the gallery, now he sits glumly at his end of the Board table, offering the barest minimum of information only when called upon. Hmmm, this is not my observation.

Brought on as a consultant to conduct an independent audit of county departments and 'entities' two years ago, Thompson was suddently (suddenly) elevated to his current position last December 2, on what has come to be known in local circles as 'The Night of the Long Knives.' (Google Germany just prior to World War II.)  Oh, please.  Who is writing this stuff?  Dick, is this you?

In that now-infamous December 2013 meeting, supervisors McKinley Daley and Henry Nickson linked up to carry out a coup.  Along with a third supervisor, Phillis Williams, Nickson and Daley put forward and passed a motion to first dismiss county Board attorney Andy Dulaney while he was performing his duties during the meeting, and the county administrator Clifton Johnson.  The replacement attorney, Ellis Pittman, and Thompson were waiting in the audience that night to be brought to the table by the 'Gang of Three," without benefit of resumes, interviews or anything that could be construed as normal business practice.  Did it ever occur to you that perhaps Andy shouldn't have been serving as the BOS's attorney and the attorney for all of the other entities?  Maybe there needed to be some division?  The "Gang of Three" didn't remove Andy from any other board as far as I know.

Thompson's rise to power was the most astonishing, considering that he appeared out of no where onto the scene in August 2012.  Despite repeated requests from this newspaper for background information, a resume' or credentials, Thompson has yet to produce anything for public consumption that would convince us that he has the knowledge, skills or experience to carry out his current county job. Hmmm, funny thing about that.  Bob and I went to his office, asked the questions and got the answers.  Why can't you do the same?

During the 16 or so months he was acting as an independent auditor, Thompson, to our knowledge, failed to make EVEN ONE written report of his activities or findings.  Not true, PowerPoint presentations were made in the BOS's meetings and workshops.  Sorry the reports were not in the format you demand.  I feel sure if the reports had been written, you would have asked for a PowerPoint presentation because he was wasting paper.

We do know he began his review of county entities with the Tunica County Utility District and the Tunica Museum, before moving on briefly to the Tunic Convention & Visitors Bureau, whose Board ultimately refused to cooperate.  Don't you find it a bit strange that some citizens can refuse to share financial information with other citizens?  And just what is the CVB Foundation all about?  To the best of our knowledge, he never, in his time as auditor, examined any county departments, despite his assurances to supervisor Phillis Williams in mid July and again in mid August that he would find cost savings during the county's budget process in August and September 2013. And the former County Administrator was so open to listening and including any cost saving measures? Yeah, right.

In the month after his sudden hiring. Thompson brought in finance consultant Alex Wiley to assist him.  Thompson and Wiley apparently have a long professional and personal association and were soon seen frequenting local restaurants and traveling together back and forth to Memphis. This is just ridiculous.  Don't most colleagues eat lunch together?  I've never heard you say anything about other employees having lunch together.  Wiley stayed on the county payroll for six months or so, his name appearing on the claims docket as late as July this year.

While Wiley was still on the payroll, supervisors filled the vacant position of county comptroller Adrian McKay, a Rosa Fort High School graduate and former resident. Adrian also graduated from Alcorn State University with a degree in accounting.  It is unclear just how much influence McKay has exerted in his short tenure.  On July 1, McKay stated in an open meeting that he had not had access to the revenue side' of the county's financial picture.  You need to get your facts straight on this one.  I believe you can remember this committee's recent report stating that $13M+ had yet to be entered into the system.  Check the Public Records.

This information came out during one of supervisor Cedric Burnett's repeated requests to Thompson in open meetings for cash in the bank statements.  Burnett even went so far as to make a records request under the Freedom of Information Act.  To our knowledge, neither Burnett nor any other supervisor has received during Thompson's tenure, a cash in bank statement or report that could give the Board an accurate picture of the county's financial standing.  Burnett is my supervisor and he needs to spend more time helping to fix the problems he helped to create then being spoon fed information.  He can go to Michael's office and get anything he wants with which to make decisions. My supervisor is disruptive, lazy and not a team player.  I have to ask, what else is he afraid will be found out?

Last August, the county leaders are normally deeply involved in budgeting for the coming year, this newspaper was told by reliable sources that Thompson was out of the county and away from his post for perhaps two weeks' time.  Here we go..."reliable sources".  Care to share?  Consequently, the administrator and the Board bungled the entire budget process, failing to produce a coherent plan of action for the fiscal year that started October 1.  Not true.

Based solely on Thompson's very tenuous verbal accounting of county finances, given on September 11, mere days before the statutory deadline to produce a final budget, the Board passed a substantial tax increase, without giving the tax paying public its statutorily guaranteed right to protest and despite ongoing challenges to the county's assessed valuations of the majority of the casino properties located here. Not true.  It was different this year and actually an improvement.  The County Administrator held workshops to inform the public and not a thing changed from the 2013 dates.

On October 10, Hollywood Casino lodged a formal appeal of the tax increase and budget process, now slowly making its way through the state's often snail-like judicial process.  I'm interested to find out what the courts have to say about our budgeting process.  Hollywood has a right to sue about the tax increase but our budgeting process?  Oh well, we shall see.

Note: The next section contains 3 bullets.  I am changing each bullet to a number for easier understanding.


Thompson's other accomplishments in his first year?  Here are the highlights:

1. an ongoing dispute with the town of Tunica.  After legislation to revise the formula that divides gaming tax revenue among the county general fund, the public schools and the sole incorporated town or city within Tunica County, the town of Tunica, failed last spring, the county acted on an earlier threat and sued the town and school district in late October,  the county is currently illegally withholding November and December gaming tax money from the town, and it is believed, the school district.  Let us say that again: the county is breaking state law and withholding the schools' and town's share of gaming taxes.

2. Tunica County has repeatedly jeopardized fire protection in its jurisdiction by failing to renew existing contracts that cover most of Tunica County.  For nearly a year, county homeowners have been under threat of a significant increase in their property insurance rates perhaps as much as double what they are paying now.  Please tell us when anyone was without Fire Protection in Tunica County.  Yes, there were discussions and negotiations and a resolution.

In North Tunica County, where a special taxing district supports a paid fire department, declining tax revenues are forcing reductions in staff to risky levels, not only endangering the lives and property of those who live in the district but also failing to adequately protect casino visitors and employees. And what would you like Mr. Thompson to do about this?  Print money?  Perhaps this taxing district will have to increase what they are paying to cover the reduction in revenues.

3. In the biggest debacle for Tunica County, Caesar's Entertainment abruptly closed the county's largest resort property, Harrah's, throwing over a thousand people out of work, shuttering three hotels, a world class golf course, Cottonwoods, and the resort area's only true convention facility, and putting an end to a successful program of charter fights (flights) into Tunica Airport, flights which were drawing visitors from far outside the drive-up market.

And now you are blaming Mr. Thompson for Harrah's closing?  Please.  And as for the Airport?  How about doing some investigative reporting on how many flights go in and out of Tunica Airport?  Make sure you include the money Tunica has spent on this facility in your findings.  Oh, and see if you can find a feasibility study that shows we needed or could support an airport.  I've looked and asked and as far as I know there isn't a feasibility study.  Who decided to build this facility anyway? Here we go again with the same answer: Former Boards of Supervisors and Former County Administrators did not make good decisions and did not do the necessary pre project work.  And now the rest of us are left to figure out how to pay for all of these facilities.  Do you have any ideas?  Oh, yeah, your idea is to get rid of Mr. Thompson.  And just how would that help?  We would still be in the same mess we are in today.






Let's talk about Cottonwoods.  Who was it who built a golf course to compete with River Bend and Cottonwoods?  We did.  Not Michael Thompson.  It is way past time we, the citizens of Tunica County, take responsibility for the mess we are in and living beyond our means.


What is it you are really mad about?  Could it possibly be that your "in crowd" did not find and approve Michael Thompson?  Could it be that you supported the Sheriff's entrapment of Mr. Thompson and are disappointed he didn't leave then?  Are you upset you didn't get enough signatures to stop the bridge loan for tax receipts?  Are you still upset about the Museum?






Let's talk about the Museum for a bit.  I support the existence of our Museum.  What I don't support are all of these separate accounts held by all of these Component Units and I still want the County to take all accounting under it's roof.  Do you happen to know that the Battle Arena just spent $10,000 for a separate audit?  Why did they do that?  With everyone and his brother out there spending money whenever they feel like it and for their own reasons, it is no wonder all purchase orders now have to be approved by the County Administrator.











Note: End of "bullets"....







Gaming revenues, already dipping, have declined significantly since Harrah's closure in June, leaving the county with even less revenue to support government services, tourism development and the creation of new manufacturing jobs that could help a local work-force that is now in double digits in joblessness.

"Now in double digits in joblessness?"  We've been in double digits for a very long time.  Below you will find the unemployment rates for Tunica, MS according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics from Jan 2008 to Oct 2014.  Both the Flood of 2011 and Harrah's closing have been indicated beside the appropriate month.





Jan 2008: 12.8%
Feb 2008: 12.4%
Mar 2008: 10.9%
Apr 2008: 8.5%
May 2008: 10.1%
Jun 2008: 9.1%
Jul 2008: 9.9%
Aug 2008: 9.9%
Sep 2008: 10.2%
Oct 2008: 9.5%
Nov 2008: 11.5%
Dec 2008: 15.4%




Jan 2009: 18.3%
Feb 2009: 16.3%
Mar 2009: 14.5%
Apr 2009: 16.3%
May 2009: 14.6%
Jun 2009: 12.8%
Jul 2009: 14.1%
Aug 2009: 13.7%
Sep 2009: 14.2%
Oct 2009: 13.1%
Nov 2009: 12.7%
Dec 2009: 17.00%




Jan 2010: 19.4%
Feb 2010: 19.8%
Mar 2010:  18.9%
Apr 2010: 16.4 %
May 2010: 17.1%
Jun 2010: 16.1%
Jul 2010: 18.0%
Aug 2010: 16.5%
Sep 2010: 15.4%
Oct 2010: 14.1%
Nov 2010: 16.1%
Dec 2010: 19.7%



Jan 2011: 21.3%
Feb 2011: 21.1%
Mar 20ll: 19.3%
Apr 2011: 17.8%
May 2011: 32.4% FLOOD
Jun 2011:20.6 %
Jul 2011: 18.2%
Aug 2011: 17.6%
Sep 2011: 15.4%
Oct 2011: 13.3%
Nov 2011: 13.0%
Dec 2011: 17.4%




Jan 2012: 18.6%
Feb 2012: 18.2%
Mar 2012: 15.9%
Apr 2012: 14.6%
May 2012: 15.9%
Jun 2012: 16.6%
Jul 2012: 16.0%
Aug 2012: 14.4%
Sep 2012: 12.6%
Oct 2012: 13.3%
Nov 2012: 13.3%
Dec 2012: 16.5%



Jan 2013: 20.5%
Feb 2013: 19.7%
Mar 2013: 16.7%
Apr 2013: 15.6%
May 2013: 14.3%
Jun 2013: 13.6%
Jul 2013: 12.6%
Aug 2013: 12.6%
Sep 2013: 11.9%
Oct 2013: 11.5%
Nov 2013: 10.1%
Dec 2013: 12.5%



Jan 2014: 17.2%
Feb 2014: 17.3%
Mar 2014: 15.5%
Apr 2014: 12.0%
May 2014: 13.4%
Jun 2014: 17.8% Harrah's Closed
Jul 2014: 18.2%
Aug 2014: 15.3%
Sep 2014: 13.1%
Oct 2014: 12.8%
Nov 2014:
Dec 2014:

This is going in the right direction?  Who are we kidding?  You said unemployment has dipped significantly since Harrah's closed.  Hmmm, looks like that's not right either.

Just this week, supervisors approved  five percent reduction in pay for county employees.  Well, Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.  You are well aware that we have too many employees.  Take a look at the Sheriff's Department and the Rec.  There is no good time to cut wages or lay employees off.  What suggestion do you have?  How about this:  The Stennis Report lists those employees who are overpaid, those who are right on target and those who are underpaid.  Let's look at those who are overpaid.  If you take the 10 highest employees and reduce their salaries to the MS Mean, we will save about $400,000 per year.  Okay, that's my first suggestion.  Your turn to come up with an idea.

By all accounts, it's too little, too late.  I believe what is too little, too late is my supervisor voting no on everything when he voted yes on building all of this stuff.  He can sit there and vote no until the cows come home and it won't change what he did in the past.  The savings produced by this reduction is a mere $30,000 per month, according to Thompson's estimate Monday, not nearly enough to close the gap between a $1.3 million monthly payroll and gaming taxes to the general fund that have fallen below $1.2 million this month (again, according to Thompson on Dec.15.)

Need to remind you again, if former Supervisors and former County Administrators had recognized our broken tax system and made corrections along the way we would be better off today.  This information was harvested by Mr. Thompson.  Another piece of the puzzle.  Taxes can't be increased fast enough to correct errors from the past. 

Additionally, in the last couple of years and before Michael Thompson, I sent a letter to your newspaper stating that we had overbuilt and would not be able to keep up with our debt.  I was questioning why all of these facilities were built without feasibility studies.  The next week you all wrote that someone who had lived here for only about 10 years need not be criticizing others for their "vision".  I didn't respond then but I will now.  Those former decision makers made decisions that have us where we are today and whether you like it or not, two of those decision makers remain on the Board of Supervisors today.  Talk about two people who need to be removed.


So, what is behind all of this?  IMHO, there is a group of Tunicans who think they have all of the answers and just how dare someone else open their mouth.  You really don't want people from other areas moving here.  So, why not put up a big sign saying if you weren't born here, you are not welcome?  Did you ever stop to think that just maybe these "outsiders" might be able to help?

















It doesn't take a genius to see that with outgoing payroll and claims of $4 million this month and something less than that coming in (again, we're not sure, since no financials are available), we're in trouble.  And it doesn't take a genius to make adjustments in taxes when revenue and assessed property values are going down.  So, why did they and why can't you publicly recognize that.










And whether this is a run of really bad luck, poor governance, weak management or a combination of all these factors, the truth is that Michael Thompson is not cutting it as count administrator. I disagree. 

It's time that Tunica County cut its losses and cuts him loose. And what will that get us?

Who knows?  It might be a relief for all of us."  Not to all of us.


The Tunica Times owes Michael Thompson an apology for all of the inaccurate blame you have attributed to him personally.  This apology needs to be front page and above the fold.  I will be waiting to see if you have the where withal to do it.